Canagan Cat Food Cans: Chicken with Prawns vs Tuna with Crab

By The Pets Larder | Published: 2026-11-02

Category: Comparisons

Compare Canagan's Chicken with Prawns and Tuna with Crab wet cat food cans on texture, protein source, and value to choose the right flavour for your cat.

Quick answer

Choose Canagan Chicken with Prawns for a shredded, land-protein base that suits cats who prefer poultry, and Canagan Tuna with Crab for flaked ocean fish with dolphin-friendly sourcing. Both are grain-free complete foods with a 65% meat-to-vegetable ratio, so the decision comes down to protein preference and texture.

Texture and protein source: the real differentiator

The two cans differ most in how the meat is prepared and where the protein comes from. Chicken with Prawns uses tender shredded chicken breast meat without skin, combined with whole prawns in natural gravy. Tuna with Crab uses flaked tuna and crab morsels, also in natural gravy. If your cat is texture-sensitive, shredded chicken offers a finer, more uniform bite, while flaked tuna gives a looser, chunkier mouthfeel.

Protein source matters for cats with preferences or sensitivities. Chicken is a familiar poultry protein; tuna and crab are marine proteins. Neither can is a hypoallergenic or single-protein diet, so if your vet has identified a specific protein allergy, check the full ingredient list before switching.

Sourcing and packaging notes

Canagan states that its tuna is ocean-caught using dolphin-friendly methods, which may matter if you prioritise sustainable fish sourcing. Both cans are fully recyclable, including the can and all packaging materials. That makes either option a reasonable choice if reducing packaging waste is part of your buying decision.

Price and value trade-off

At catalog prices, Tuna with Crab is listed at USD 1.03 against a comparison price of USD 1.59, while Chicken with Prawns is USD 1.19 against USD 1.59. That makes the tuna recipe the lower-cost can at the moment, but prices can change and size options affect the final cost per serving. If your cat accepts both, the tuna can stretches the budget further; if your cat prefers chicken, the small difference may not justify forcing a switch.

Trade-offs to weigh before you buy

Protein preference: If your cat consistently leaves fish or poultry, choose the can that matches the protein they already accept. Chicken with Prawns is poultry-based; Tuna with Crab is marine-based. Offer a small amount of each before committing to a multipack.
Texture tolerance: Shredded chicken suits cats who prefer a finer, more uniform texture; flaked tuna and crab suit cats who like looser, chunkier bites. If your cat has dental issues, observe which texture they manage more comfortably.
Budget and sizing: Tuna with Crab is currently the lower-priced can at USD 1.03 versus USD 1.19 for Chicken with Prawns, but both come in multiple sizes. Compare cost per gram for the size you will actually buy. Check the size options before assuming the smaller can is better value.
Ingredient sensitivities: Neither can is a limited-ingredient diet. If your cat has a diagnosed allergy to chicken, fish, or shellfish, consult your vet before introducing either recipe.

Product facts at a glance

Canagan Cat Food Can - Chicken with Prawns: Tender shredded chicken breast meat without skin with whole prawns, cooked in natural gravy. The shredded texture and skinless chicken make it a good fit for cats who prefer poultry or need a finer consistency.
Canagan Cat Food Can - Chicken with Prawns
Canagan Cat Food Can - Tuna with Crab: Flaked tuna and crab meat in natural gravy, with tuna ocean-caught using dolphin-friendly methods. The flaked texture and dolphin-friendly sourcing appeal to cats who like fish and owners who care about how the fish is caught.
Canagan Cat Food Can - Tuna with Crab

Which can suits which cat?

Best for

Cats that prefer poultry and shredded textures (Chicken with Prawns)
Owners who want dolphin-friendly fish sourcing and a lower-priced can (Tuna with Crab)

Not for

Cats on a vet-prescribed elimination diet or with confirmed protein allergies
Owners looking for a single-protein or limited-ingredient wet food