Back to Blog
Product Reviews 2026-11-16 The Pets Larder 0 views

Eco Cat Toys with Catnip: Mr Spooky vs Lobster Teaser

Eco Cat Toys with Catnip: Mr Spooky vs Lobster Teaser

Compare Green and Wilds Mr Spooky and House of Paws Lobster Teaser: materials, catnip, size, care and supervision, so you can pick the right eco catnip toy.

Two eco catnip toys, two different play styles

Green and Wilds Mr Spooky and House of Paws Lobster Teaser are both eco-friendly catnip toys, but they are built for different kinds of play. Mr Spooky is a compact wool-felt ghost with a jute string, while the Lobster Teaser has an elasticated spring for bounce. Neither toy is indestructible, and both need supervision, so the right pick depends on how your cat likes to hunt, pounce and chase.

This comparison sticks to what the product records confirm. Where a detail is not supplied, such as exact dimensions for the Lobster Teaser, I flag it as a limitation rather than guess.

What each record confirms

  • House of Paws Lobster Teaser Eco Cat Toy: House of Paws Lobster Teaser Eco Cat Toy is made from recycled materials, includes catnip, and has an elasticated spring for extra bounce. The spring and catnip are the core play features; recycled material is the eco credential.
    House of Paws Lobster Teaser Eco Cat Toy
    House of Paws Lobster Teaser Eco Cat Toy
  • Green And Wilds Mr Spooky - Eco Cat Toy with Catnip: Green and Wilds Mr Spooky is made with sustainable natural wool felt and jute string, and includes added catnip. Natural materials and catnip make it a different texture and scent experience from the Lobster Teaser.
    Green And Wilds Mr Spooky - Eco Cat Toy with Catnip
    Green And Wilds Mr Spooky - Eco Cat Toy with Catnip

Materials, movement and catnip compared

The two toys differ most in how they move and what they are made from. Use this table to match the toy to your cat's preferred play style.

  • Material and eco credentials: Lobster Teaser: recycled materials. Mr Spooky: sustainable natural wool felt and jute string, produced without added compounds that would harm or be released when chewed, and fully recyclable.
  • Movement and play style: Lobster Teaser: elasticated spring adds bounce to mimic natural movement. Mr Spooky: lightweight wool-felt shape with jute string for swatting and chasing; the string length may vary.
  • Catnip: Both include catnip. Mr Spooky notes kittens under 3–6 months usually don't respond because they lack the necessary neural pathways.
  • Size and weight: Mr Spooky: 8 cm x 7 cm x 3 cm, average weight 17 g. Lobster Teaser: dimensions and weight are not supplied in the record, so check the listing or pack when it arrives.

Size and suitability details

  • Green And Wilds Mr Spooky - Eco Cat Toy with Catnip: Mr Spooky measures 8 cm x 7 cm x 3 cm and weighs about 17 g; the attached jute string length may vary. A small, light toy suits batting and carrying; the variable string means you should check it before each play session.
  • House of Paws Lobster Teaser Eco Cat Toy: The Lobster Teaser record does not list dimensions or weight. If size matters for your cat or your storage, ask before buying or compare in person if possible.

Care and supervision: what the records require

Both toys need active supervision. The records give specific care limits that affect how long they last.

  • Supervise all play: Mr Spooky's record states pets should always be supervised when playing with toys. No toy is indestructible. Remove the toy if your cat tries to swallow any pieces or chunks.
  • No machine washing: Mr Spooky is not machine washable. The Lobster Teaser record does not supply cleaning instructions, so follow any care label on the product and avoid assuming it can go in the machine.
  • Retire damaged toys: Because no toy is indestructible, check seams, strings and springs regularly and replace if pieces loosen or detach.

Which cat is each toy for?

Choose Mr Spooky if your cat likes light, textured toys they can swat, carry and chase, and you prefer natural wool felt and jute over recycled synthetic materials. Its small size and 17 g weight suit cats that bat toys around rather than wrestle them. The catnip may not interest kittens under 3–6 months, so treat it as a toy for older kittens and adult cats.

Choose the Lobster Teaser if your cat responds to bouncing, springy movement and you want a recycled-material option with catnip. The spring adds unpredictability that can trigger chasing and pouncing. Because dimensions are not supplied, check the size if your cat is very small or very large, or if you need to know it will fit under furniture.

Neither toy is a chew toy or a food product. Mr Spooky's record explicitly says it is a cat play toy only and not a food product, and both need supervision to prevent swallowing.

What the records do not settle

The supplied information does not include exact dimensions or weight for the Lobster Teaser, cleaning instructions for either toy beyond Mr Spooky's no-machine-wash note, or durability testing for either product. It also does not confirm whether the Lobster Teaser's catnip is loose or sewn in. Use the records as a starting point, and check the packaging or contact the store if a detail is critical to your decision.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile