Two Natural Instinct Recipes, Two Different Nutritional Profiles
Natural Instinct offers two complete raw dog foods that serve different needs: Special Diet and Working Dog Chicken & Salmon. Both are grain-free, made in Britain, and free from artificial colours, additives, or preservatives. The key difference lies in their fat content and intended use. Special Diet is a low-fat recipe designed for dogs with specific dietary concerns, while Working Dog Chicken & Salmon is a higher-fat formula for high-energy working dogs. This comparison breaks down the supplied facts so you can decide which recipe aligns with your dog's requirements.
Special Diet: Low Fat for Sensitive Dogs
- Natural Instinct Special Diet: Fat content 4.6% A low-fat recipe is often chosen for dogs with pancreatitis, colitis, irritable bowel syndrome, or those needing to lose weight.
Natural Instinct Special Diet - Natural Instinct Special Diet: Ingredients include beef white tripe (50%), chicken with bone (20%), beef liver (5%), vegetables, and fruits. The high tripe content provides a novel protein source and the low bone content (20% chicken with bone) may suit dogs needing reduced bone intake.
- Natural Instinct Special Diet: Created for dogs that suffer from pancreatitis, colitis, and irritable bowel syndrome and great for overweight dogs that need to shed some weight. This directly states the recipe's purpose, helping you match it to a vet-diagnosed condition.
Working Dog Chicken & Salmon: High Energy, Higher Fat
- Natural Instinct Working Dog Chicken & Salmon: Fat content 14.8% This higher fat level supports the energy demands of active working dogs.
Natural Instinct Working Dog Chicken & Salmon - Natural Instinct Working Dog Chicken & Salmon: Contains human-grade chicken meat with bone (50%), salmon (35%), vegetables, fruits, and extra vitamin C. The combination of chicken and salmon provides a mix of proteins and omega-3 fatty acids, while vitamin C supports the immune system, joints, and ligaments.
- Natural Instinct Working Dog Chicken & Salmon: Made for high-energy, working dogs. This indicates the recipe is formulated for dogs with elevated energy needs, such as working or very active dogs.
Side-by-Side: Key Nutritional Differences
- Fat: Special Diet: 4.6% | Working Dog: 14.8%
- Protein: Special Diet: 14.8% | Working Dog: 13.2%
- Calcium: Special Diet: 0.4% | Working Dog: 0.8%
- Phosphorus: Special Diet: 0.3% | Working Dog: 0.6%
- Primary protein sources: Special Diet: beef white tripe, chicken, beef liver | Working Dog: chicken, salmon
Which Recipe Fits Your Dog?
If your dog has been diagnosed with a condition such as pancreatitis, colitis, or irritable bowel syndrome, or needs to lose weight, Special Diet is the appropriate choice based on the manufacturer's description. Its low fat content (4.6%) and low bone content are designed for these situations.
For dogs that are highly active, such as working dogs or those in strenuous activities, Working Dog Chicken & Salmon provides the higher fat (14.8%) and energy needed to support their lifestyle. The inclusion of salmon offers a different protein profile and added vitamin C for joint and immune support.
Always consult your veterinarian before changing your dog's diet, especially if your dog has a medical condition. The supplied information does not include feeding amounts or transition guidance; those details should be confirmed with your vet or the manufacturer.
What the Supplied Information Does Not Confirm
Neither product record includes preparation instructions, defrosting guidelines, or feeding quantities. These are critical for safe raw feeding, so you should refer to the packaging or contact the manufacturer directly. Additionally, while both recipes are described as complete and balanced, the specific nutritional adequacy statement (e.g., AAFCO) is not provided in the supplied facts. Always check the label for the most current information.
